Other TV roles included CSI: Miami and Fringe. In 2008, she appeared in the movie Nick and Norah’s Infinite Playlist. Graynor was in the comedy film, Whip It, in 2009. Between 2010-2011 she appeared in the Broadway plays Trust and Relatively Speaking. In 2012, she starred in the comedy For a Good Time, Call… (which she also produced) and on Broadway in the play The Performers.